Read A Wind in the Door by ★★
This book has some lovely concepts. I liked the conception of dragons as cherubim (and much more imaginative than the sunday-school version of either), and the idea of Naming/Unnaming is like something I have read in George MacDonald. However, the book has several major problems. The plot shoves its way awkwardly around, forcing you to accept that things are happening in a way that feels extremely contrived, especially since much of it is left unexplained. The pace drags on at an interminably slow pace and then the happy ending happens ridiculously fast. The narrative is grows increasingly vague; towards the end I was often at a loss about what exactly the narrative was supposed to be helping me picture in my head — it might have had to do with the fact that the pace was so slow that I was unconsciously skimming in order to get to where things were happening. Many of the plot devices were just too ambitious, implausible and relied too heavily on jargon. By the end the narrative is so full of kything, farae, mitochondria, farandolae, senex, ecthroi, etc etc etc that it begins to look like a salad of jargon more than anything else.
I liked its predecessor, A Wrinkle in Time, which had some fantastical concepts woven into a sound plot. This book tries way too hard. I felt it was more of an education in writing by counterexample than an enjoyable fictional experience.