Joel Dueck · Library ·

Cover of The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe

Watched The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005) dir. Andrew Adamson ★½

The writers tried to key up certain scenes emotionally by introducing a conflict between Susan and Peter that parallels the conflict between Edmund and Lucy. In this new dynamic, Peter is now a fragile snowflake man-child who fancies himself an authority figure, but in moments of crisis randomly displays bold unhesitating courage (running back inside to get Edmund during the air raid) or freezes up and wets his pants (any time he is holding a sword and there is a wolf around). Susan is the disapproving stick-in-the-mud upon whom magic and wonder have no effect. Each loathes the other, with good reason, while betraying no self-awareness whatsoever. The emotional affect of this conflict never lands, despite several attempts. So they end up making two of the four leads stupid and unlikable with no payoff.

Skandar Keynes (Edmund) was given a good character in this movie and performed it well. Everyone else either was given a terrible character and gave a passable performance (Tilda Swinton, James McAvoy, Georgie Henley, Kirah Shah) or was given a terrible character and didn’t do it well (everyone else). Aslan was the absolute worst.

Other than that: lots of obvious green-screening. A never-ending parade of unearned moments. But the battle at the end is pretty cool.