Joel Dueck · Library ·

Cover of The Shadow of Kyoshi

Read The Shadow of Kyoshi by F.C. Yee ★

I’ll start by saying I enjoyed the first book in the series. This one is airless and joyless, a dry book about court intrigue and politics, with occasional action scenes where the Avatar freezes up inexplicably and gets her ass kicked. Like the worst Harry Potter books, the main emotional lever in the story is people being peevish and irritated with themselves and each other. Nobody (including Kyoshi) fundamentally grows, learns or changes in this story. There are no arcs, just a series of events that are supposed to be more and more devastating and saddening until somehow it’s all over. The final battle reads like an action-figure game of pretend; ultimately they turned the tide in some unexplained way by…putting on improvised makeup. Two of the characters weep and hug each other while the villian who has been shooting to kill the whole time inexplicably decides to just stand there and watch. I was just cringing the whole time I read this book.