Personal libraries
After I created the Library section of this site, I collected all the good examples of other library-style collections published on personal websites that I could recall.
These libraries are not merely lists of things-read-or-seen; they are tools for thought, ladders for climbing up the Literacy Gradient.
A Working Library
The best, longest-lived example. I’ve read Mandy Brown’s website for nearly two decades now. The site is essentially a library, titled A Working Library. Enter at any post or review, and the links will pendulate you back and forth between her essays and her book collection.
She writes about reasons for publishing a website, and for shaping it as a library:
A website is, among other things, a container. The shape of that container both constrains and makes possible what goes within it. This is, I think, one of the primary justifications for having your own website. Not just so you can own your stuff (for some meaning of “ownership,” in a culture in which any billionaire can scrape your work without permission and copyright only protects the rich). Not just so you have a home base among the shifting winds of the various platforms, which rise and fall like brush before the fire. Not just so you can avoid setting up camp in a Nazi bar. But also so that you can shape the work—so that you can give shape to it, and in that shaping make possible work that couldn’t arise elsewhere.
I made a decision many years ago to shape my work around the books I read. If I’m being completely honest, I don’t recall spending a lot of time thinking about that decision or contemplating the consequences of it. It seemed right and so I ran with it. But it has since given rise to a kind of scholarship and writing that I’m not sure I would have landed on were I writing on some all-purpose platform, or fitting my work into someone else’s box. It’s allowed me to cultivate the soil to suit my purposes—rather than having to adapt my garden to the soil I was given. Not every seed I’ve planted has thrived, of course. But after all these years, some are quite hardy, while others have made some very rich compost.
Applied Cartography
In a 2016 blog post, Justin Duke mentions that in
college he listed his favorite movies and books on his site, “because I was still a
pretentious liberal arts student.” But he thought of better reasons for the practice and has
published a rated, reviewed catalog of books and movies since at least 2020, first on
arcana.computer and on jmduke.com since 2024.
First: a rule I set for myself a few years ago was that if I was going to consume anything — any media at all — I would have to write myself a little book report at the end of it, to avoid consumption for consumption's sake. This has been a great habit, and I highly encourage it. I write these for no one but myself; my readership is still overwhelmingly dominated by entrepreneurs and engineers, and I harbor no fantasy nor illusion of that ever changing.
But it feels both important and virtuous — and frankly, fun — to spend so much of my time critically writing about something that isn’t what I do for work. Which is to say: the act of thinking carefully about art, of forcing yourself to articulate why something moved you or didn’t, is a different muscle entirely from the one I exercise when writing about Django or pricing strategy or whatever else. It’s good for you. It’s good for me.
V.H. Belvadi
Venkatram Belvadi keeps a bookshelf section on his site for reviews of select books, and a much, much larger reading list as a comprehensive log of everything he’s read. It’s neither the central paradigm of his work nor the result of a personal rule or practice; it’s simply a handcrafted secretary (in the furniture sense) built by a person who loves to read, to receive and organize his thoughts on what he reads.
Craig Burrell
Craig Burrell has been posting on this Wordpress blog All Manner of Thing, in which he mostly reviews the books and plays he reads, for almost twenty years now. I am not sure how or when I first found it, but I’ve had it in my RSS reader for most of that time.
I keep this site in my pocket as a counterweight to my ideas about what is important.
It’s not lovely, and has never once been redesigned, maybe never even tweaked, in its
near-twenty years of existence. It is long-lived, but on borrowed time; with every new year
Craig has extended his gamble that he will be able to keep the wordpress.com
domain being loaned to him by his blogging platform, and so far the internet gods have been
kind, or he has evaded their attention.
I wouldn’t even say I resonate often with his selections or his opinions.
Ultimately, all it has going for it is that Craig reads a lot, and writes thoughtfully about what he reads, consistently and without fail. Every book or play gets a blog post. That’s it.